- What happens?
- What about the call?
- Should they have played it?
Further in 6.D.10 it states, "In doubles play, if one player calls the ball “out” and the partner calls it “in,” then doubt exists, and the ball must be declared “in” (except that any player may appeal a call to the referee in an officiated match).
6.D.12. If, while the ball is in the air, a player yells “out,” “no,” “bounce it,” or any other word to communicate to his or her partner that the ball may be out, it shall be considered player communication. If the ball lands in, play will continue. If the out call is made after the ball has hit the playing surface, it shall be considered a line call and play shall stop. (revised April 1, 2011)
Based on these rulings, and how I've been playing those rules I would say my partner was in the best position to make that difficult line call, and if he played it then play should continue. If the opponent got confused between my yelling that it was out, and my partner saying the ball was in and playing the return, and the opponent stops play, then all parties can agree to replay, if not then benefit of the doubt goes to the opponent.
Unless I hear otherwise, and often in a loud gymnasium, it is hard to hear all line calls of our opponents, I will play my returns until play stops completely by my opponent waving their paddle to stop, or my partner yelling stop play, or fault is made.
Players should know the rules!
ReplyDeleteA ball can not be called out until it touches the playing surface.
This is the reason for 6.D.12
Any call prior to the ball touching the ground is player communication.
In your example,the partner was correct and play should have continued.
A ball is neither in or out until it touches the playing surface.
If a player wanted to move to the next skill level and learn to control his or her swings, Do not hit the ball when it is an out ball, It is difficult to control your swings, you will learn to control your swings by taking responsiblity to your swings. If you hit an out ball then call it an in ball, don't try to have it both ways, your games will never improve. Advance players can control thier swings and that is how they do it. Do not decide where to hit the ball when it is still in the air, make your decision when to hit the ball after the ball bounced. Try to hit the ball on the fall rather than on the raise, this way you will not hit an out ball. If in some instant that you cannot control hitting an out ball, call out before you hit it,
ReplyDelete